Trail of Tears Lesson

Background

It is 1830. The population of  U.S. citizens in Georgia is growing rapidly and pushing into the western portions of the state. However, the Cherokee nation occupies a large area of western Georgia. Treaties signed between teh United States and the Cherokees guaranteed them the rights to this land, but settlerrs have begun to move into these territories, sparking conflicts with teh Cherokees that were growing voilent. The discovery of gold within the Cherokee territory in 1828 has only made the situation worse. At the urging of President Andrew Jackson, the Committee on Indian Affairs drafted a bill that would give the President the power to order the removal of all Native Americans living east of the Mississippi River to designated lands west of the Mississippi.

Persuasion Paper/Debate Activity

Research the reasons for "removal" of the Cherokee Indians. Read President Jackon's first and second annual messages, delivered in 1829. Choose a viewpoint (President Jackson or Cherokee Indians) and write a persuasion paper with discussions points on why the Cherokees should be removed or why they should stay. Or, divide the class in two sections and debate the issue.

Hint: Prior to becoming the President of the United States, Andrew Jackson was an army general who spent years leading campaigns against the Creeks in Georgia and Alabama and the Seminoles in Florida.

Trail of Tears Routes

The first of three groups of Cherokees departed Tennessee in June 1838 and headed to Indian Territory by boat, a journey that took them along the Tennessee, Ohio, Mississippi and Arkansas rivers. Approximately 2,800 people traveled by boat. Heat, extended drought and disease soon made travel along this water route impractical, so that fall and winter thousands more Cherokees were forced to trek from Tennessee to present-day Oklahoma via one of several overland routes. Federal officials allowed Chief John Ross to take charge of these overland removals, and he organized the Indians into 13 groups, each comprised of nearly a thousand people. Although there were some wagons and horses, most people had to walk.

The route followed by the largest number of Cherokees - 12,000 people or more, according to some estimates - was the northern route, a distance of more than 800 miles through Tennessee, Kentucky, Illinois, Missouri, Arkansas and into Indian Territory. The last groups of Cherokees made it to Indian Territory in March 1839. (Exerpt from history.com)

While the numbers vary, it is believed that about 4,000 Native Americans died on the Trail of Tears.

Trail of Tears Resources

Trail of Tears Video

 

Trail of Tears Map

Trail of Tears Northern Route Map

Trail of Tears Northern and Water Routes Map

Map related questions fromTeaching with Historic Places National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior 

Discover the Trail of Tears: A Lightning Lesson from Teaching with Historic PlacesQuestions for Map

  1. One of the largest groups of Cherokee left Tennessee in the late fall of 1838. Accompanied by Federal troops and missionaries, the group followed the far-northern routeand arrived in Indian Territory by March. This was a land route. Based on the Map evidence, list three challenges you think they faced while making a land journey on foot.
  2. Find the water route. What rivers does it follow? What advantages do you think this route may have had over the land route? How might it have been more difficult than traveling over land? Cite evidence in the Map to support your answer.
  3. If you were part of a Cherokee group faced with the choice of the land or water route, which would you want to travelWhy? List two pieces of evidence from the Map and one piece of evidence from your own experiences to support your answer.