Comparing Number Memorization in Tactile vs. Visual Readers

By Laura Hospitál on Jul 10, 2015

This science project was done by Carrie, who is a student at Texas School for the Blind and Visually Impaired (TSBVI).
 
 
Carrie was interested in testing memory related to print versus braille readers.  This project was one of several ideas that she considered.  She worked very independently on her science project.
 

Hypothesis: 

My hypothesis was that visual learners would memorize more numbers than tactual learners.

 

Materials

  • large 17"X20" printer paper
  • 20/20 marker
  • Perkins Braille writer
  • braille paper
  • print reading volunteers
  • braille reading volunteers
  • a quiet space to test
The image is of the first four cards made for this project.

Procedure

  1. Write a series of nonconsecutive numbers on note cards, (braille and print on separate cards). On the first note card you will write one number, on the second notecard you will write the first number plus another number. On the third note card you will write the first two numbers plus a third number. You will continue this on twenty notecards.
  2. You will need to ask for volunteers for your experiment.
  3. For a braille or print user, pass them the first notecard with the number. Give them five seconds for every five numbers to memorize. Show them the first card for five seconds. Then have them repeat the number that they saw. If they get that number correct, show them the second note card for five seconds.
  4. If they get those numbers correct show them the third card. Do the same for the rest. 
  5. Record your results; the number of numbers each volunteer memorized. The average of numbers memorized by print users and then the average for the Braille users. 
  6. You can make a graph to show the differences.

Conclusion: 

My conclusion is that braille users memorize more numbers with a larger variety than print users, while the print users memorize less numbers with a smaller variety.  My hypothesis was not supported.  

NGSS Standards:

Plan and conduct an investigation individually and collaboratively to produce data to serve as the basis for evidence, and in the design: decide on types, how much, and accuracy of data needed to produce reliable measurements and consider limitations on the precision of the data (e.g., number of trials, cost, risk, time), and refine the design accordingly. (HS-ESS2-5)
 
number memorization collage
Read more about: STEM